Bah Bah Bah... no I haven't turned into a sheep but I am extremely annoyed at Simon Cowell... as are a lot of other people... if you don't care about X factor don't bother reading this.
OK you know I'm not the target X factor audience... like I'd never buy their Christmas single or anything and I know that it's a money-making scheme, so that's not a shock or anything, but there really is a fine line between what the public will accept as a scenario designed to bring out emotions and manufactured drama. Once it goes over the line they totally lose interest, which has been seen with things like Big Brother. X factor has been happily swinging along that line for the last few years. It's a big prize and there seems to be consensus that people with talent in singing should compete for this singing prize... and Simon Cowell actually saying what he thinks without worrying about people's feelings has been part of the magic.
But it's gone wrong for the last two weeks. And it isn't Jedward's fault. Jedward are annoying, but I can see how they would be great on a Saturday morning kids show. They shouldn't be booed, but no-one should vote for them. Most years there's been some sort of slightly dodgy novelty act in the final 12... so fine... people find them funny despite (or perhaps because of) the negative feedback they've got from Dannii, Cheryl and Simon. And because in this show you vote FOR someone to stay in and not AGAINST someone, the votes of all the people who want Jedward to go and spread across the other acts. Again this is fine, but as the numbers get smaller the spread of votes is thinned out and Jedward are not going to get any new votes. So it was unsurprising that they were finally in the position of possibly being booted on Saturday. And we're all thinking finally we're getting down to it - separating the wheat from the chafe... but true to form from the previous week Simon sent it to deadlock, siding with the weaker singer(s). He keeps defending his position saying that that Lucie would not have won and that it was up to the public who decide. Bollocks Mr Cowell, Bollocks I say, so are you saying, Mr Cowell, that you shouldn't be a judge? Well fuck off then!
His decision is the beginning of the end for X factor. And, you know, Simon was terribly bored by the whole audition process so maybe he's so sick of his cashcow that he'll burn the show down with Jedward at the top. I mean it wouldn't be the first time his label had a crap act and it won't be the last. So that was it... I can see a lot of people switching over to strictly, because it's one thing to find a novelty act entertaining for a couple of weeks, it's quite another to see a so-called-expert so clearly take the 'heighten the drama' route picking the shitest option. So now its so clearly manufactured drama that no-one can deny it.
However I'm not sure if I'm so sickened that I will stop watching... I mean I might well... I suppose we'll see next week. My three favourites are still there: Stacey, Jamie and Olly. My TV commitments tend to be suddenly changeable... if I switch off it is likely that I'll switch off for good.
Actually my big surprise in all this is how much I find myself liking Dannii Minogue... I mean historically I would never have liked her. I didn't like her when she started in the show. I think I got to like her a little last year because Ruth was my fave and they were great mates. This year I noticed a big change, because she's all happy and positive, and has moved away from the plastic face (botox is a bad idea people), but when she said 'I obviously did something wrong' when asked how she felt about Lucie leaving, it actually brought a tear to my eye... something Dannii Minogue said brought a tear to my eye! I could never have predicted that. Fuck Simon let's have Dannii as the main judge!
OK you know I'm not the target X factor audience... like I'd never buy their Christmas single or anything and I know that it's a money-making scheme, so that's not a shock or anything, but there really is a fine line between what the public will accept as a scenario designed to bring out emotions and manufactured drama. Once it goes over the line they totally lose interest, which has been seen with things like Big Brother. X factor has been happily swinging along that line for the last few years. It's a big prize and there seems to be consensus that people with talent in singing should compete for this singing prize... and Simon Cowell actually saying what he thinks without worrying about people's feelings has been part of the magic.
But it's gone wrong for the last two weeks. And it isn't Jedward's fault. Jedward are annoying, but I can see how they would be great on a Saturday morning kids show. They shouldn't be booed, but no-one should vote for them. Most years there's been some sort of slightly dodgy novelty act in the final 12... so fine... people find them funny despite (or perhaps because of) the negative feedback they've got from Dannii, Cheryl and Simon. And because in this show you vote FOR someone to stay in and not AGAINST someone, the votes of all the people who want Jedward to go and spread across the other acts. Again this is fine, but as the numbers get smaller the spread of votes is thinned out and Jedward are not going to get any new votes. So it was unsurprising that they were finally in the position of possibly being booted on Saturday. And we're all thinking finally we're getting down to it - separating the wheat from the chafe... but true to form from the previous week Simon sent it to deadlock, siding with the weaker singer(s). He keeps defending his position saying that that Lucie would not have won and that it was up to the public who decide. Bollocks Mr Cowell, Bollocks I say, so are you saying, Mr Cowell, that you shouldn't be a judge? Well fuck off then!
His decision is the beginning of the end for X factor. And, you know, Simon was terribly bored by the whole audition process so maybe he's so sick of his cashcow that he'll burn the show down with Jedward at the top. I mean it wouldn't be the first time his label had a crap act and it won't be the last. So that was it... I can see a lot of people switching over to strictly, because it's one thing to find a novelty act entertaining for a couple of weeks, it's quite another to see a so-called-expert so clearly take the 'heighten the drama' route picking the shitest option. So now its so clearly manufactured drama that no-one can deny it.
However I'm not sure if I'm so sickened that I will stop watching... I mean I might well... I suppose we'll see next week. My three favourites are still there: Stacey, Jamie and Olly. My TV commitments tend to be suddenly changeable... if I switch off it is likely that I'll switch off for good.
Actually my big surprise in all this is how much I find myself liking Dannii Minogue... I mean historically I would never have liked her. I didn't like her when she started in the show. I think I got to like her a little last year because Ruth was my fave and they were great mates. This year I noticed a big change, because she's all happy and positive, and has moved away from the plastic face (botox is a bad idea people), but when she said 'I obviously did something wrong' when asked how she felt about Lucie leaving, it actually brought a tear to my eye... something Dannii Minogue said brought a tear to my eye! I could never have predicted that. Fuck Simon let's have Dannii as the main judge!




